Depends on what you think is old. The "Old" phones were made of bakelite. Most were your basic Black, and then there was Black and, of course, black. About the only thing that can bring that kind of plastic back is a good automotive rubbing compound. There are several grades of grit, so be careful and start with a less abrasive compound and, if the scratches and blemishes are proving to be resistant, then move on up to a more abrasive compound.

If your "old" phone is made of a lighter thermoset plastic, Rather Be Fishing gave you the best answer.

Rcaman

Americom, Inc.
Where The Art And Science Of Communications Meet